Old Bag of Nails served its last meal at 66 N. Sandusky St. on Sunday, Oct. 11, after 22 years downtown. As Delaware Source reported, drawing on Columbus Business First, it had been on a month-to-month lease since its original 20-year lease ran out in 2024. The company wanted a long-term lease and couldn't get one. It also offered to buy the building, and the offer was turned down.
Two blocks away on William Street, the operator behind downtown's two newest bars started by buying a building. Taken together, the two stories describe how downtown Delaware is changing right now. A long track record on Sandusky Street didn't secure a future there. Control of the property did.
Two Years Without a Long-Term Lease
The closing in October grew out of a timeline that started almost three years ago:
- 2004: Old Bag of Nails opens at 66 N. Sandusky St. under a 20-year lease.
- January 2024: NBC4 reports that the 6,600-plus-square-foot building is for sale at $1.9 million and marketed as a well-tenanted investment.
- 2024: The original lease expires, and the pub stays on month to month.
- September 2026: The building's commercial listing is updated, weeks before the announcement, according to 1808Delaware.
- Oct. 6, 2026: The pub announces it will close.
- Oct. 11, 2026: Last day of service.
The pub stayed open for more than two years with no long-term lease. Its farewell post said it was "unable to reach a long-term agreement with the landlord that would allow us to continue operations."
The asking price also moved. When NBC4 reported the listing in January 2024, the price was $1.9 million. As of October 2026, 1808Delaware reports $1.7 million to buy, or $18 per square foot per year to lease. That's $200,000 lower after almost three years on the market. The same marketing describes the Delaware pub as the fourth-ranked Old Bag of Nails location in the chain. So this was a busy location, and it still lost its lease.
What 66 N. Sandusky Is Being Marketed As
The building dates to 1920 and has 6,651 square feet. It's within walking distance of Ohio Wesleyan University and the busiest stretch of Sandusky Street. The listing calls it a fully built-out restaurant and bar with a large central bar, a commercial kitchen, an outdoor patio and dedicated parking.
The kitchen, bar and patio are already in place, so the next tenant may well run another restaurant or bar. That's an inference, though. Columbus Navigator reported on Oct. 13 that, without a long-term commitment to the property, the company decided it didn't make sense to invest in the upgrades and other improvements the building needed.
Whoever buys or leases the building will decide what opens there. For now, the property is available both ways.
Two Blocks Over, the Newest Operator Started by Buying
Downtown's other recent openings came from John Cordas, who also owns Shorty's Pizza and Sandbar Station in Delaware. In March 2026 he opened Open Btl at 39 E. William St., a bottle shop and wine and spirits bar with wine club memberships, tastings, retail bottles, cocktails and small bites.
His group bought the building. Cordas told Delaware Source that "one of the contingencies for us buying this building, actually, was approval from the building department that they would approve a rooftop patio." The rooftop was part of the deal from the start. Delaware Source reported in August that the rooftop was set to open to the public the last week of August. Plans called for a weather-permitting patio for year-round use with lounge seating, fire pits, happy hours and performances.
His second downtown spot, Hallihan's Irish Pub, held its grand opening Sept. 14 at 12 W. William St. The group took over the space in February. According to Delaware Source, Hallihan's is the first business to use the building's upstairs. Cordas told the Delaware Gazette that the pub came from business partner Mike Barker, owner of CBUS Title Agency, whose firm handled the title work when the group bought the Open Btl property.
All three addresses have changed hands among businesses before. The 39 E. William St. history comes from the Delaware Gazette and 1808Delaware, and the 12 W. William St. history comes from 614NOW:
| Address | Built | Earlier occupants | Status as of mid-October 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 66 N. Sandusky St. | 1920 | Old Bag of Nails, 2004 to Oct. 11, 2026 | Listed for sale or lease |
| 39 E. William St. | 1955 | Mundy's service garage until 2004; Amanda Plumbing Sewer and Drain until 2020; J. Gumbo's until early March 2025 | Open Btl, building bought by the operator |
| 12 W. William St. | Not reported | 12 West, closed 2020; Lazy Dawg, closed 2025 | Hallihan's Irish Pub, opened September 2026 |
The table shows how often these spaces turn over. The William Street building that now holds a wine bar has been a garage, a plumbing company and a Cajun restaurant within about 20 years. It's not public whether Cordas's group owns or leases the Hallihan's building. At Open Btl, buying the building gave the operator control over the rooftop and over how long it stays.
Where the Fish and Chips Went
For anyone who ordered fish and chips at Old Bag of Nails, the closest option downtown is now on William Street. Cordas told the Gazette that Hallihan's fish and chips are hand-battered in a special batter, served with a house tartar sauce that has "a tiny little kick" and a plain homemade version too. The Reuben uses corned beef slow-cooked for six hours. Shepherd's pie and bangers and mash rotate through the menu, and bangers and mash is a Sunday special. October's monthly special is shepherd's pie. The pub plans to open early for major soccer and rugby matches.
"We don't have any traditional Irish pubs," Cordas told the Delaware Gazette when describing why his team chose the concept.
Old Bag of Nails regulars can still find the chain nearby. The company's locations page lists a Westerville pub at 24 N. State St. #26 and a Worthington pub at 663 N. High St.
One more Sandusky Street change for the morning crowd: Espresso Air opened Aug. 12 at 34 S. Sandusky St., serving coffee, teas, smoothies, chai and matcha.
The Downtown Calendar Through December
Main Street Delaware's schedule keeps people coming downtown while 66 N. Sandusky sits empty:
- Saturday, Oct. 31, 9 a.m. to noon. Trick-or-Treat Down Main Street runs with the season's final Farmers' Market. Participating vendors and businesses will hand out treats.
- Friday, Nov. 6, 6 to 9 p.m. November First Friday: Community Harvest features Delaware County nonprofits and service groups, the City of Delaware's Paint-a-Plow display and a pie-eating contest at Fresh Start. A Nov. 6 to 15 business food drive benefits Delaware County United to Fight Against Hunger.
- Tuesday, Nov. 10, 6 p.m. Friendsgiving at Oak & Brazen Wine Co. includes a Thanksgiving-style meal from Two Chicken Farm and desserts from Wildwood Farm Bakes. Tickets are listed at $75 per person or $120 per couple.
- Dec. 4 to 6. Home for the Holidays opens Friday with the First Friday Tree Lighting from 6 to 9 p.m. Free skating behind the Delaware Welcome Center at 20 E. William St. runs 5 to 9 p.m. that night, provided by Snappy's Automotive and its Mason Foundation. Saturday brings Dash for Dasher from 11 a.m. to 1 p.m. and the Great Gingerbread Build Off at COhatch at 3:30 p.m. The "Light the Night" Christmas Parade steps off from Mingo Park at 6 p.m. Sunday and travels down Sandusky Street to Wilmer Street. Tree-lighting and some Santa times are still listed as TBD.
The next thing to watch on Sandusky Street is a sale or lease announcement for 66 N. Sandusky. That deal will decide what opens behind the central bar and patio the pub left behind.
I've followed downtown Delaware for a long time, and its buildings often outlast the businesses inside them. If you own a building downtown, lease one, or are weighing a buy against a lease for a small commercial property, I'm glad to talk through how similar properties around here have been changing hands. Sharon Staub. Let's Connect.