Walk through Heritage Park on a Thursday night in mid-October and you'll find the whole 60-acre space glowing. Carved jack-o'-lanterns line a trail that winds past food trucks and glow-in-the-dark mini golf. Kids in costumes are climbing on bumper cars. This is the version of Westerville Halloween most people picture when they think about the season here, and it's a real one. The Great Westerville Pumpkin Glow runs October 15 through 18 this year, ticketed, city-run, big enough that organizers expanded it to use the entire park for the first time.
But drive four minutes away on the same night and you'll find a completely different Halloween happening on a residential street, run by one family, free to attend, funded by donations to two veterans' charities. Walk into Uptown on a different weekend and you'll find a third version: a $27 ticketed walking tour that starts at a 19th-century cemetery and ends at a pub, built entirely from local ghost stories. Step inside the public library any day in October and you'll find a fourth, where a tarantula gets passed hand to hand and a decommissioned phone booth answers with a Doctor Who bit.
These four events offer different experiences, though some of their dates overlap. They are not four versions of one city festival; each is organized independently.
Four Events, Four Different Landlords
It's easy to assume a town's Halloween lineup all flows from one calendar, probably city hall's. Westerville's doesn't. Here's who actually answers for each event, and where.
| Event | Who Runs It | Where | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Great Westerville Pumpkin Glow | City of Westerville Parks & Recreation | Heritage Park, 60 N. Cleveland Ave. | Ticketed |
| Uptown Ghost Story Tours | Uptown Westerville Inc, a nonprofit | Starts at Otterbein Cemetery, ends at the Old Bag of Nails | About $27 per person |
| Slaybrook Manor | Local organizers | Unincorporated Genoa Township | Free, donations to veterans' charities |
| Wizards & Wands Festival | Westerville Public Library | 126 S. State St. | Free |
Three of those four sit inside the city limits and answer to Westerville's own government or a nonprofit chartered to serve Uptown. The fourth doesn't. Slaybrook Manor carries a Westerville mailing address, but the parcel sits in unincorporated Genoa Township, which means its future isn't decided by Westerville City Council at all. It's decided by township trustees.
Slaybrook Manor and Genoa Township
Slaybrook Manor started small, a neighborhood project that grew out of a love for Halloween and a desire to give something back to the neighborhood. It became an official, named event in 2024. What visitors find is not a garage with a few cobwebs strung up. It's more than five dozen handmade sculptures, animatronics, and built sets, all constructed by the family that runs it, all offered for free. Donations collected at the door go to two veterans' organizations, K9s For Warriors and Homes For Our Troops.
Genoa Township is currently rewriting its zoning code. A petition asking township trustees Mark Antonetz and Annette McMurry to protect community-driven events like this one by name has circulated this fall. The organizers describe it plainly: this isn't a business seeking a commercial permit, it's a residential haunt that grew organically into a neighborhood tradition, and they want the township to include it in the new code.
The dates are already posted, running weekend nights in October with later hours on Halloween itself. Slaybrook Manor is located in unincorporated Genoa Township, outside Westerville city limits.
The Big Production, Rain or Shine (Usually)
The Pumpkin Glow is the version built to scale. This year's four nights, October 15 through 18, spread across the whole of Heritage Park rather than a portion of it, with the trail routed through new sections of the grounds. New additions include glow-in-the-dark mini golf and bumper cars alongside the artist-carved pumpkin displays and food trucks that have anchored the event in past years.
It's also a genuinely weather-dependent operation, which is worth knowing before you plan a specific night around it. Last October, the event's final scheduled evening was canceled outright when continuous rain left the grounds too soft to safely host the crowds. If you're building an evening around the Glow this year, treat the earlier nights in the run as the safer bet and keep an eye on the city's own event page for changes.
The One Built From Local Ghost Stories
Uptown Westerville Inc runs the other ticketed option, and it's not a haunted house. It's a history tour with a theatrical edge. The walking tour covers about six blocks and twelve stops, starting at Otterbein Cemetery and ending at the Old Bag of Nails, which occupies the historic building once known as the Weyant Building. Performers from Good Medicine Productions carry the tour, and the stories themselves are drawn from actual local history rather than invented for the occasion.
Two of the stops illustrate the difference. One traces back to May 17, 1886, when a touring theater company performing Uncle Tom's Cabin at what's now the Old Bag of Nails accidentally started a fire that killed two nine-year-old children and an adult woman. Another comes from Otterbein Cemetery itself, a local legend from the 1840s involving a farmer named James Henry, two women he courted in succession, and a horseshoe-shaped mark that appeared on a headstone. Whether you take the ghost stories at face value or not, the tour is doing something the other three events aren't: turning Westerville's own 19th-century history into the entertainment, rather than importing generic Halloween scares.
This year's tour is confirmed to be running again, with dates beginning the weekend of September 25 and continuing on select Friday and Saturday nights into Halloween weekend, consistent with the schedule the tour has followed in past years.
The Indoor Option, and the Rest of the Ecosystem
Westerville Public Library takes a different approach entirely, spreading its Wizards & Wands Festival across the full month of October rather than a single weekend. The library's programming leans into age-graded activities that let a family split up by interest: an escape room for older kids, a life-sized Candyland walkthrough for younger ones with a sensory-friendly version offered separately, and a pumpkin parade for the very youngest. Live animal visits are a recurring feature of the festival, with reptiles, birds of prey, and other creatures brought in alongside animal ambassadors from the Columbus Zoo.
Two more pieces round out the month without needing their own headline. Hoover Gardens & Gift Center on North Sunbury Road runs an annual haunted maze inside its greenhouse, aimed at families who want a milder scare alongside a stop for mums and pumpkins. And Uptown's designated outdoor refreshment area lets adults carry a seasonal drink between shops during Fourth Fridays on September 25 and October 23, turning an evening of window shopping into something with a bit more occasion attached.
Picking the Right Night
None of these four events is trying to be the others, which is exactly why a single weekend in Westerville can look completely different depending on which one you pick. If you want a big, planned-out evening with food trucks and rides, the Pumpkin Glow's four nights are built for that. If you want something free that plugs directly into the neighborhood and a cause worth supporting, Slaybrook Manor delivers that on a residential street built entirely by one family. If you're drawn to actual town history dressed up with a bit of theater, the Ghost Story Tour is the one built for that purpose. And if you've got a toddler and a middle schooler with wildly different tolerances for scares, the library's month-long run is the only one flexible enough to serve both under one roof.
The calendar is only one part of daily life here.
If you're weighing what a season like this says about a neighborhood, whether that's the strength of its civic organizations, the reach of its parks system, or the ways residents contribute to local events, that's the kind of texture worth understanding before you buy a home here, not after. If you'd like to talk through what a specific Westerville street or neighborhood actually offers day to day, Sharon Staub would be glad to walk through it with you. Let's Connect.